The Cartonera Project 2017: Every Student IS an Author {SOL 5.16.17}

Last Thursday, our school held our annual Cartonera Celebration, a celebration of every student being an author.

That's right....EVERY kindergarten through grade 5 student wrote, edited, illustrated, and published a cardboard book. (A cartonera is a book with a cardboard cover. You can find more information about them in this video.)

It was quite an accomplishment, to say the least!

Last Thursday was the day the entire school took a break from what we were doing and for one hour, we read and commented on each other's cartoneras. Students met up with their character ed buddy and walked around together, stopping often to read a cartonera together.

Even the teachers got in on the fun.

After reading a cartonera, the reader left a compliment on the Raves From Readers page.

The students could hardly wait to get back to their classroom to read their Raves From Readers comments. They were incredibly empowering and demonstrated the effect of writing for an authentic audience.

Then in the evening, we invited families to school to read the cartoneras and to make a family cartonera to take home to write their family story.

We also had Paloma Celis Carbajal, a bibliographer and cartonera expert from the University of Wisconsin - Madison visit us. She brought with a few of the cartoneras from the UW collection, the largest collection of cartoneras in the United States, for our kids to check out.

Here's what some of my students had to say about the Cartonera Project:

"When the books were published, I felt accomplished."
"It was fun to walk around with my buddy to read books without my teacher." :)
"It kind of proves that you don't need to be a pro to write a book."
"I enjoyed getting to fix up a story and make it better."
"It was amazing and I thought it was cool. Everyone should do this!"

       Isn't that AWESOME??!!?

I am incredibly proud to have been a part of this celebration of writing and sad that the event is over. I am already thinking of ways to grow the program and make it even better, including expanding the project to other schools to connect students and classrooms from around the country in the spirit of writing.

If you are interested in learning more about possibly bringing a Cartonera Project to your school or classroom and would like to learn more, please fill out this Google form. When I get the information together, I will be in touch.

The Importance of an Authentic Audience

If you've done any research about teaching writing, you've probably learned how important it is for students to write for an authentic audience whenever possible. When kids know they are writing for someone other than the teacher, their motivation and quality of writing drastically improves.

"(Our students) have to believe that what they have to say is important 

enough to bother writing. They have to experience writing for real audiences 

 they will know that writing can bring them power."

-- Anne Rodier,  National Writing Project

"A Cure for Writer's Block: Writing for Real Audiences"

In our writing workshop, we are working on informational writing. For my students' first published piece, I was their only reader.

The books a few of my students wrote were fresh and interesting, but then the quality of writing from these students usually is.  For the most part, however, a majority of the writing was as dry as a desert in July.

How could I blame them for not showing much excitement for this writing project?

I knew I had to mix things up for our next published piece.  Big time.

I figured a new audience was the way to go.

I spoke to our school librarian and she agreed that my students could display their finished books in our library for other students to read during library class. She said she would even give the books a Dewey decimal number to make them more authentic and would display them on top of the book stacks where published books usually sit.

Our art teacher jumped in to help too. She will have the kids paint and decorate a book cover on cardboard in art class over the next few weeks. We will add their writing inside, making it a real book called a cartonera.  (You can read more about cartoneras and our schoolwide writing celebration, The Cartonera Project, here .)

Finally, I announced to my class that I plan to keep their books (cartoneras) and take them with me to three conferences I am presenting at this summer about our school Cartonera Project. Their books, I told them, would be seen by hundreds of teachers from around the United States.

All of a sudden, eyebrows started perking up. Mouths began dropping open. A rustle went through the room.

With a new audience, came new motivation and interest in our writing project.  I'm pretty sure all of my students will produce their best work yet!

How do your students write for an authentic audience? I'd love if you would leave me a comment and share.

Slow Down for Practice

I've been thinking a lot lately about the pace at which I teach, especially when it comes to writing time.

The list of skills and strategies students must learn is a mile long.

Every day, I teach a mini lesson. We practice it. We talk about it.

The next day, we repeat.

I hope (wish, pray) that my students will learn the daily concept and apply it to their writing, magically transforming themselves into expert writers by the year's end.

But the truth is that in 5th grade, I still have students who cannot identify a fragment from a complete sentence, tell the difference between dialog and description, and can write five pages without a paragraph's indent in sight.

Why don't they get this? I frustratingly wonder to myself.

Maybe....it has something to do with pace.

Yes, mini lessons are important, but so is practice time. Students need time to practice and play with the new concept, to take ownership of it. If we are constantly rushing to the next lesson without allowing time for this to happen, it's no wonder that some kids can't write a coherent paragraph when they get to high school.

I'm going to try to be more aware of how much practice time I offer my students before moving on to the next skill.  My hope (wish, prayer) is that with more time, my students will internalize more writing moves that will help them grow into strong lifelong writers.

Should Students Know Their Reading Level?

Last week, I came across this post titled "A Level is a Teacher's Tool, NOT a Child's Label" from the Fountas and Pinnell blog.

F & P are gurus of reading assessment, so the post quickly caught my attention.

If you don't have time to read the post from F & P (although I hope you will), here are a few highlights that really hit me:

* Reading levels should guide, not limit, student choices when choosing a book for independent reading. (Donalyn Miller, The Book Whisperer, has said this too.)

* Reading levels aren't meant to be shared with students OR parents. They should not appear on a report card or in a teacher's evaluation.

* Reading levels are an estimate, not an exact measure of a student's reading ability.

* Reading is not about moving up levels, it is about enjoyment and building a lifelong habit. (Yep!)

* Reading levels are a teacher's tool to be used for assessment and instruction only.

This got me thinking about how I communicate with my student readers about their progress.

I do not use the F & P system for assessing my students, but we do take the Star Reader test every month to check for progress. (It is even a component in my teacher effectiveness plan.)

My students keep a chart in their goal notebook to track their growth. Some months, there are cheers as good growth is made.  Other months, they take a peek at their new score and quickly shut their notebooks.

This made me think about an assessment experience that I think many of us can relate too -- getting on the scale when I am trying to lose weight.  When the numbers on the scale go down showing good growth in my weight loss goals, I am happy and motivated to keep going. But when the numbers are stalled, or even worse, go up, I am deflated and want to go find a pack of Oreos and gallon of milk, ready to give up.

I need to think more about the post from F & P and how I can communicate reading growth to my students in a way that is positive, motivating and accurate.

I think the answer lies in conferring.

Do you have any suggestions?

Wait List

It was quiet reading time the other day when I heard two of my students deep in a muffled negotiation about a book. They were whispering back and forth then I saw an exchange between them.

One student opened the cover of the book, pointed to a Post-it inside, then handed the book to the other student. The other student put aside the book he was reading (Diary of a Wimpy Kid) and began reading his new trade.

I was curious as to what was on the Post-It so I went over to ask. I smiled when I saw that it was a Wait List of students who wanted to read the book.

The book?

The Seventh Wish by Kate Messner.

If you haven't read it, you should add your name to the Wait List. My kids know a good book when they see one.

Research Writing: Forget the "Expert" List

As I was writing my plans for our new research writing unit, I was concerned that my students would write about something they already knew a lot about, thereby foregoing the need to really dig deep into their research. By 5th grade, most kids have figured out on their own that if they choose a topic to research that they already know a lot about, their job will be easier.

But this unit was to be more than just about writing. I wanted them to learn something about their topic and really get into the research process too.

Knowing this, I thought of a way to help my students choose a fresh topic to research....and here's how:

We began by creating a list of everything we were an expert at or knew a ton about. I set the timer for three minutes as my kids wrote away. Creating this list was easy.

When the three minutes was up, we created another list -- a non-expert list. These would be the things we've always wondered about, wanted to learn more about, or held our curiosity. Another three minutes on the timer, but creating this list was a bit tougher for many.

After both lists were created, I asked the students to look at their expert list and circle the thing they knew the most about. We then did a whip around the room and as each student read his or her most expert topic, everyone either added it to their own expert or non-expert list. This helped the lists grow.

When we were finish sharing, I told my class to put a giant X through their expert list. They could not choose a topic for this project from their expert list.

      Shock!

            Horror!

                  Gasp!

After I explained that this writing project would not just be about writing, but should also teach us something, they understood the method to my madness. Everyone relaxed and got busy picking a new topic to research that would take them from having non-expert to expert status in no time!

Mission accomplished.

Students Need a OLW Too!

Happy new year!

As we return to school this coming week, it is the perfect time to plan for and set goals for the new year.

Many of us do this in the form of a resolution, but I prefer to choose a word that will serve as my mantra and guiding light for the year. It's just easier to remember than a bunch of things that I will or will not do that come in the form of a resolution. (Even the word 'resolution' sounds harsh, doesn't it?)

By now, you may have chosen your One Little Word (OLW) for 2017. But have you considered having your students choose an OLW as a part of their goal-setting for the new year?

I have put together some resources for you to use to make this easy and fun.

This video can get things started:

This graphic organizer will help students choose a word. You can find it here.

Once students have chosen their word, they can reflect on how they will use it to meet their goals. This graphic organizer will get them thinking and help organize the writing process. You can find it here.

Looking for other ways to bring your students' OLW to life?

* Work with the art teacher to have students create a graphic representation or collage of their OLW.

* Give students a mailing label. Have their write their OLW on the label as a sort of name tag to wear.

* Students include their OLW after they write their name on their papers.

* Students write in their reflection journal at the end of every day of how they called on their OLW for guidance in decision making and action.

* Change name tags on desks (or add another one) to include students' OLW. This will help keep the word front and center during work times.

* Create a class book of OLW's. (Thanks Beth Foraker @inclusionchick for the suggestion!)


Best of luck to you as you begin 2017! I wish both you and your students much success in meeting your goals this new year!